Study finds no benefits of screening for thyroid dysfunction in nonpregnant adults

Study finds no benefits of screening for thyroid dysfunction in nonpregnant adults

A new guideline from the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care recommends against routine screening for thyroid dysfunction in nonpregnant adults without symptoms or risk factors.
This guideline, which is based on a rigorous systematic review of the latest evidence, is published in CMAJ.

Routine testing for thyroid dysfunction is commonly ordered, by checking the "thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH)" box on a blood test requisition form, although practice varies by primary care practitioner.

An abnormal TSH level may indicate an underactive (hypothyroidism) or overactive thyroid gland (hyperthyroidism).

If you are a clinician who orders TSH tests as part of preventive health visits, we would like you to reconsider this practice. The evidence isn't there to suggest a health benefit for this type of screening as a routine part of care."
Dr. Richard Birtwhistle

Emeritus Professor of Family Medicine and Public Health Sciences at Queen's University and Chair of the Task Force Thyroid Dysfunction working group.

The task force identified no screening trials in their evidence review but looked at 22 studies on the effectiveness of treatment for abnormal TSH findings in asymptomatic adults and found no evidence of benefits from screening and treatment in people without symptoms.

Harms of unnecessary testing include the need to take medication unnecessarily and have regular medical visits and follow-up blood tests to check TSH levels.

"Patients who are unusually tired; sensitive to cold or heat; or experience hair loss, heartbeat irregularities, unexpected weight loss or gain should visit their primary care practitioner," says Dr. Donna Reynolds, a family doctor and specialist in public health and preventive medicine and a member of the task force working group.
"This recommendation does not apply to people with symptoms that may indicate an over- or under-active thyroid gland, or who have risk factors for thyroid disease, such as previous head or neck radiation, exposure to certain medications, and pituitary or hypothalamic diseases."

Alignment with Other Guidelines

The British Columbia Ministry of Health and Toward Optimized Practice from Alberta recommend against testing for TSH in asymptomatic patients.

The College of Family Physicians of Canada, Nurse Practitioner Association of Canada and the Canadian Society of Endocrinology and Metabolism have endorsed the guideline.

"Given the lack of clinical effectiveness and the burden on patients, including financial costs, screening patients without symptoms consume resources that could be better used elsewhere," says Dr. Birtwhistle.

In a related commentary Drs. Omar El Kawkgi and Juan Brito, Division of Endocrinology, Diabetes, Metabolism and Nutrition, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, write that "by issuing a strong recommendation against population screening for thyroid dysfunction, the task force may help physicians to stop uncovering a large reservoir of people with mild thyroid dysfunction who are unlikely to benefit from identification or treatment, thereby preventing the overdiagnosis and overtreatment of otherwise healthy people."

They note that the task force's recommendation diverges from some other medical societies that recommend screening, especially in older people.

Canadian Medical Association Journal

No comments